So who will the farmers blame?


Who will the farmers blame when the sugar industry has to cope with reduced sugar prices from the European Union without the aid the EU has promised to help cope with lower prices?Prices are going to fall, and I mean really fall. A small drop this year (2008/9) of 14 percent less than 2006/7 will be followed in 2009/10 by a drop of 36 percent in the EU internal price which is the basis of prices for countries with preferential access to the EU.

If farmers are struggling now, how will they fare when the price of sugar is slashed?

Before the coup the sugar industry was already in a mess. Leases were expiring and land was remaining idle. Under the leadership of Mahendra Chaudhry. the National Farmers Union had no chance of finding a solution to the lease problem. Chaudhry’s divisive style means that he is distrusted by landowners and he could never support a solution that involved compromise on rent levels.

Chaudhry also damaged the sugar industry by extracting from the FSC a share of the sugar revenue for his farmers that left the FSC nothing to reinvest in proper maintenance or new equipment.

Chaudhry could always tell his faithful followers that it was the fault of the Qarase government but after nearly two years of Chaudhry and his minions running the industry things are worse than ever. Mill breakdowns are a daily occurrence and transport of cane to the mills is hampered by poor roads and rail systems.

But what about the rest of the world? It hasn’t stood still while we allow a vital industry to decay. There are many new producers who will make it hard for Fiji to compete.

In 2000 Mozambique produced 45,000 tonnes of sugar but had no exports to the EU. In 2007 they produced 243,00 tonnes and exported 77,351 tonnes to the EU. Uganda, Tanzania Swaziland and even Sudan, are also increasing their production steadily. They all have new investment in irrigated cane and new mills.

Unless we can dramatically lower costs, our sugar industry is doomed. We have to replant with higher yielding varieties and consolidate farms to achieve efficiencies of scale. And we have to get our mills modernized and working properly.

A lot of our smaller farmers will have to leave the industry, which is why the EU has offered assistance to allow our farmers to adapt to

the drop in prices and the opening of the EU market to foreign competition.

Are our cane farmers aware of these dramatic changes and the impact they will have on them? Not yet.

Mahendra Chaudhry has always built his support base among cane farmers by focusing on his enemies within Fiji, creating conflict to allow himself to look like a hero. The Qarase Government and the people it appointed to the FSC board and the Fiji Sugar Cane Growers Council were always easy targets for Chaudhry.

But Chaudhry has had to keep quiet for the past two years because all of his people now dominate the FSC Board and the FSCGC.

But what will he say now that EU aid is under threat because Frank has decided to thumb his nose at EU representatives?

Chaudhry will go on the attack because it’s the only game he knows. His problem will be who to target? It can only be Frank.

But who will the farmers blame? Some will follow Chaudhry wherever he goes, like the rats behind the pied piper, but the majority will have no doubt that Frank and Chaudhry are both to blame for wrecking an industry that feeds a quarter of our workforce.


Bloggers, don’t forget to register on because our smart strategies beginning next year will be lobbying Governments about their citizens involved in treason in Fiji and people like John Samy lobbying his former employer like the ADB to ensure, they do not touch him again for the rest of his natural life!


4 Responses to “So who will the farmers blame?”

  1. Mark Manning Says:

    If one was to follow Frank and Chaudhry’s example of Economic Policy , there would be no Public Servants , so money could be saved there .
    No services would be provided , so there would be further savings , no services = no cost to the Government .
    Everyones wages would be reduced to 1900 wages and taxes doubled . ????????????????????????????????????????
    Sound Economic MIsmanagement indeed !

  2. lutu Says:

    Sugar industry in my opinion is worth saving, our people are just beginning to turn to the land to make their living.We’ve gotta sent people abroad to learn how to run this industry.
    Florida, South America, Cuba etc, are some of the sugar producing areas where the FSC should have sent people to, for studies and observations. No need to shut this industry down. Fijian can definately run it at this point of our development.
    The problem is that Chodo, has made sure to installed, his own people in every important areas, of this industry, so that if and when he knows that his grasp, is slipping away from its control, all he has to do is pull the plug and the industry, will immediately comes to a full stop?
    I think that Qarase saw, what the Chodo was doing to this important industry and was on the right track, in trying to rectify the problem, when dumbass Bainimarama, with Chodo encouragements, illegally pulled the military coup in 2006.

  3. Nostradamus Says:

    What is the truth behind this Fiji Times article

    Landowners Arrested For Illegal Trespass
    Publish date/time: 19/12/2008 [07:20]

    Sigatoka police arrested a group of landowners from Nabitu, Ruwailevu, Nadroga yesterday after allegedly illegally occupying the leased land belonging to more than 400 tenants.

    Landowners issued eviction notices to these tenants claiming that their leases had expired.

    Sigatoka police confirm six landowners are currently in custody.

    Speaking on behalf of the landowners, Kalivati Batibasaga said the Interim Government, Native Land Trust Board and other stakeholders are all aware of the matter since the issue was brought to them in 2006

  4. Keep The Faith Says:

    For starters farmers can blame Frank because this little tantrum is going to absolutely kill the sugar industry – believe it. As it is the whole sector is already hanging on a thin thread:

    If Frank expels the NZHC, the knock-on effects on sugar will be as evident as night and day.

    The farmers should also be re-assessing whether Mr Ma’chaud really have their interests at heart or not because barking in the media is very easy to do – just put out a press release and circulate to media houses…and then just keep reacting reacting reacting via the same way.

    Ma’chaud doesn’t even have to show that he’s talking to the IIG to influence them on sugar decisions — he just does the talking via the media and the faithful few like fiji village will lap up every doggone word.

    What the sugar farmers need is tangible actions and the big idea that will get money coming in to revive the industry so that they can export more. Dabbling in land issues is the least of their worries. At the moment the product itself is sub-standard. We can’t even attempt to market this product as having some kind of “edge” over African or Carribbean states!

    Unfortunately even the 09 budget appears to prioritise “national security” over an industry that affects many, many, many more people.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: